The Psychology of Persistence: Why Being Told You’ll Fail Can Actually Increase Drive in Entrepreneurs
A recent study (source: https://www.sciencedirect.com/science/article/pii/S088390262600011X?via%3Dihub) explores something that shows up often in both psychology and entrepreneurship. When people are told they will fail, they sometimes become more persistent, not less.
It is a finding that sits at the intersection of motivation, identity, and how the nervous system responds to perceived threat.
As a psychologist who works primarily with high performers, and as someone who has built a business from the ground up, this pattern is familiar. It shows up in very real and very human ways.
When an Idea Becomes an Extension of Identity
The researchers describe this response as the underdog effect. In clinical terms, it often overlaps with what we might call wounded attachment or identity fusion.
What it looks like in practice.
When someone dismisses your idea, it is rarely experienced as neutral feedback if your identity is tied to what you are building. It lands as something much more personal.
It is no longer just “they do not like the idea.”
It becomes “they do not believe in me.”
At that point, the nervous system responds as though something is at stake. Not metaphorically, but biologically. The brain does not always differentiate between social threat and physical threat. A skeptical investor, a critical colleague, or a dismissive comment can all register with your nervous system as danger.
The alarm goes off.
Why Criticism Can Increase Motivation at First
For many entrepreneurs and high performers, that internal alarm creates energy.
It sharpens focus and increases urgency. It can move someone from hesitation into action. The emotional charge of being underestimated can become a powerful ignition point.
This is the part that often gets romanticized.
“I will prove them wrong.”
And in the short term, that can absolutely work.
The Nervous System Has a Cost for Sustained Threat
The challenge is what happens when this state becomes the foundation rather than the spark.
When the nervous system is operating from perceived threat, stress hormones like cortisol are more likely to be elevated. Over time, this can shift how the brain processes information.
The prefrontal cortex, which supports planning, reflection, emotional regulation, and strategic thinking, becomes less available. Meanwhile, more reactive survival-based systems take over.
In that state, a person can still push forward, but the quality of thinking changes.
There is less flexibility, less curiosity and less capacity to integrate feedback without defensiveness.
It becomes harder to access the kind of grounded creativity that entrepreneurship actually depends on.
When Persistence Becomes a Loop Instead of a Direction
This is where wounded attachment patterns tend to show up most clearly.
People may continue working hard, but the internal experience shifts. The goalpost keeps moving. External success does not fully land. Even wins can feel temporary.
And feedback from others becomes difficult to metabolize.
Instead of being something to consider, it often becomes something to defend against or something that confirms a pre-existing fear.
“I am not good enough.”
“This will not work.”
“They were right.”
Over time, this can create a loop where the work is no longer only about building something meaningful. It becomes about managing internal threat responses and protecting identity.
That is a heavy load for any creative or entrepreneurial process.
What Changes the Pattern
The shift is not about losing ambition or becoming less driven. It is about changing the internal system that is driving the persistence.
The early spark of “I will prove them wrong” is often emotionally powerful, but it is not always sustainable.
What tends to be more stable is quieter and more grounded.
It sounds more like:
“This matters to me.”
“I believe in this enough to stay with it.”
“I can hear feedback without losing myself in it.”
That requires a different kind of psychological capacity.
It means being able to notice when the nervous system is activated rather than led by it. It means pausing long enough to distinguish between useful feedback and perceived threat. It means staying connected to values rather than identity protection.
The Quality of Persistence Matters More Than Persistence Itself
Persistence is often treated as an unqualified good in entrepreneurship and high performance spaces.
But persistence is not a single thing.
It can be fueled by clarity, values, and grounded conviction. It can also be fueled by threat, insecurity, and the need to disprove something internally.
Both can look similar from the outside.
The difference shows up over time in sustainability, wellbeing, and the ability to adapt when things do not go as planned.
Grit that is grounded in self-awareness tends to create steadier, more sustainable progress.
Grit that is driven by unresolved emotional threat can produce momentum, but it often comes with a cost that is only visible later.
The work is not to eliminate drive.
It is to understand what is driving it and to channel it with intention.
Supporting Mental Wellness in Everyday Life
At Core Psychology, we understand that stress, burnout, overwhelm, and mental load don't just show up in therapy sessions. They influence everyday decisions, from relationships and parenting to work and even grocery shopping.
Our team supports adults, parents, couples, and professionals who are looking to better understand themselves, reduce stress, and create more balance in their lives.
Core Psychology
Marda Loop, Calgary
403-488-8912
admin@corepsychology.com
We offer in-person counselling in Calgary and virtual therapy throughout Alberta. If you're feeling overwhelmed, stretched thin, or stuck in patterns that no longer serve you, we're here to help.
